SE Valley Times

Arizona State Rep. Justin Heap (R-10) criticized a Biden Administration housing policy Heap said "punishes good behavior to incentivize irresponsibility."

"It's hard to imagine a worse government policy," tweeted Heap.

Heaps' tweet was in response to a letter, signed by Arizona State Sen. Jake Hoffman (R-15), that called on the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) to end a new policy he says will “penalize home buyers with good credit.”

“We write to you in support of the 34 state financial officers that have called on you to rescind your agency’s policy that will penalize home buyers with good credit by making them pay more on their mortgages every month,” said the letter, signed by Hoffman and 11 other legislative representatives of State Freedom Caucuses around the country. 

Hoffman's letter, sent to FHFA Director Sandra L. Thompson, is a follow-up to a letter sent to Thompson earlier this month by 34 state financial officers, including State Treasurer Kimberly Yee (R-Ariz.), about the new policy. 

Yee and the financial officers said the new policy “will have the net effect of making it significantly more expensive for people with good credit to buy houses.”

“Incredibly, those who make down payments of 20 percent or more on their homes will pay the highest fees — one of the most backward incentives imaginable,” said the letter.

Under the new rule,  if you have a credit score of 740 or higher, on a $500,000 loan, you would pay a fee of 0.25%, which is $1,250. After that date, you could pay as much as 0.375% - or $1,875 - on that same loan,” reported ABC 7 Los Angeles. “People with lower credit scores will pay a lower rate.” 

“There is no spreadsheet or formula dreamed up in a Washington, D.C. agency that would make our constituents believe that it is somehow more fair and equal to punish and tax people who are saving for a first home than those that have no made the same commitment,” said Hoffman's letter.

“Your agency appears to be unaware that for most people outside of Washington, D.C., a house is not just a financial asset, but a dream and a solid foundation from which to build a family,” said the letter. “Our constituents are home buyers, not house buyers. Arbitrarily making that dream harder for them to achieve and sustain is disrespectful, unfair, and financially irresponsible.”